Ваш браузер устарел. Рекомендуем обновить его до последней версии.

Author Guidelines

Legal Bulletin · Peer-Reviewed Journal

Aim and Scope. Legal Bulletin publishes scholarly articles examining the current state of Russian and foreign legislation, law enforcement practice, and proposals for improving various branches of law. The journal covers methodological, theoretical, and historical aspects of public law, civil law, and criminal law phenomena, and studies legal institutions of Russia and foreign countries.

Manuscripts must comply with the requirements set out below and be carefully proofread by the author.

On This Page:

· Technical Parameters

· Manuscript Structure

· Use of Generative AI

· Title

· Abstract

· Keywords

· References

· Author Information

· Authors' Contributions

· Personal Data

· Submission Checklist

· Manuscript Structure Table


1. Technical Parameters

 
ParameterRequirement
Software Microsoft Word (.docx)
Font Times New Roman
Font size 14 pt
Line spacing 1.5
Margins 2 cm on all sides
Length (1 author) 20,000 – 40,000 characters with spaces
Length (2 authors) from 26,000 characters with spaces
Length (3 or more authors) from 32,000 characters with spaces
Originality at least 75% (plagiarism report required)

Length is calculated excluding the abstract, keywords, graphs, figures, tables, references, and the AI disclosure.

Exceeding the specified length is possible only by agreement with the editorial office.


2. Manuscript Structure

2.1. Required Elements

The following materials must be submitted to the editorial office:

  • UDC and LBC codes;

  • article title;

  • abstract;

  • keywords;

  • manuscript text;

  • references;

  • author information.

The title, abstract, keywords, and author information must be provided in both Russian and English.

2.2. Text Sections

Recommended structure:

  • Introduction — statement of the problem, review of scholarly literature on the topic.

  • Materials and Methods — methodology, sources, methods of analysis, and the AI disclosure (see Section 3).

  • Results.

  • Discussion.

  • Conclusion.

For theoretical, historical-legal, and dogmatic works, authorial section headings are permitted, provided that the work clearly contains: a statement of the problem, a literature review, methodology, presentation and discussion, and conclusions.


3. Use of Generative AI

Generative AI and AI-assisted services (ChatGPT, Claude, DeepL, YandexGPT, and similar) are permitted as auxiliary tools for language work, text structure, and literature search. They may not act as an author or co-author of a publication, nor be used to generate scholarly conclusions, primary data, or research images.

The author bears full responsibility for the content of the manuscript, including fragments prepared with the use of AI.

3.1. Where to Disclose

The disclosure is placed in the "Materials and Methods" section as the final paragraph. If the work's structure does not provide for such a section, the disclosure is placed in the first section of the main body (e.g., at the end of the "Introduction") or in a "Methodology" subsection.

3.2. If AI Was Used

The following must be indicated:

  • the name of the tool or service (with version, if applicable);

  • the purpose of use;

  • confirmation that the author has reviewed and edited the result.

Form:

"In preparing the manuscript, [service name, version] was used for [purpose]. The author has reviewed and edited the result and bears full responsibility for the content of the publication."

3.3. If AI Was Not Used

A brief declaration is provided:

"Generative AI and AI-assisted technologies were not used in preparing the manuscript."

3.4. What Requires Disclosure

 
ScenarioDisclose?
Spelling, punctuation, basic autocorrect No
Machine translation of abstract or keywords Yes
Generation or paraphrasing of substantive text fragments Yes
Literature search via an AI service Yes (naming the tool is sufficient)
Bibliography formatting, transliteration No
Creation of diagrams, charts, illustrations Yes
Statistical data processing Yes

The disclosure is not counted toward the manuscript length. Full rules are set out in the Generative AI Policy.

Manuscripts without a disclosure (or without a declaration that AI was not used) will not be considered.


4. Title

The title must be informative, concise, and reflect the essence of the material.

When translating the title into English, transliteration from Russian is not permitted, except for untranslatable proper names and names of objects.


5. Abstract

5.1. In Russian

  • Length: 200–250 words (approximately 2,000 characters).

  • Placed after the title and author information.

  • Reflects: relevance, main goal, problems under consideration, methods used, conclusions.

Abbreviations and symbols, other than commonly used ones, are used only in exceptional cases or are defined at first mention.

5.2. In English

For the English-speaking reader, the abstract is the primary source of information about the article. It must be written in high-quality English using accepted terminology.


6. Keywords

5–10 terms in the nominative case that:

  • reveal the content of the publication;

  • reflect its scholarly concept;

  • allow the reader to quickly find the article.


7. References

7.1. General Requirements

The reference list (References) is provided in both Russian and English and includes all scholarly works used by the author. References to new scholarly literature are encouraged.

Each reference includes: author(s), title, place of publication, year, publisher, total number of pages. Where applicable — editor, compiler, translator, book series. A "dot and dash" separator is placed between description areas.

Order: sources are arranged in order of citation.

In-text citations: ordinal number in square brackets. A page reference is separated from the source reference by a comma. Multiple sources within one set of brackets are separated by a semicolon.

Examples: [1, p. 25], [1, p. 26; 5, p. 17]

The author is responsible for the accuracy of information, citations, and references.

7.2. What Is Not Included in the Reference List

  • articles from non-scholarly journals and mass media;

  • normative, legislative, and judicial acts;

  • statistical collections and archives;

  • electronic resources (online articles, news resources, organizational websites, reports and studies on websites);

  • dictionaries, encyclopedias, reference books;

  • reports, notes, memoranda, protocols.

Normative legal acts, judicial decisions, anonymous and electronic sources not indexed in citation databases are cited in in-text footnotes. They are not included in the reference list.

References to official documents must include the date, number, full title, and official source of publication.

7.3. Volume and Self-Citation

  • At least 10 sources; including foreign sources is recommended.

  • Self-citation rate — no more than 20%.

7.4. Reference Identification

All references to articles must be identified. Include DOI and/or EDN codes.

For automatic reference identification, use the eLibrary "Citation Link" service: elibrary.ru/find_edn_list.asp

If a source has a DOI, its inclusion in the References section is mandatory.

7.5. Formatting References

References are formatted in accordance with the requirements of international citation databases:

Author. Article title in English // Official journal title in English (if absent — transliteration using the BSI system). — year. — issue. — pages.

Example:

Kirillova O. V. How to arrange an article and scientific journal to avoid indexing errors in international scientometric databases. Science Editor and Publisher. — 2018. — No. 3. — P. 52–72. (In Russ.) DOI:


8. Author Information

The following must be provided in both Russian and English:

  • full name (first name, surname, patronymic);

  • academic degree;

  • academic title or status;

  • position;

  • affiliation with department (without abbreviations; the generally accepted translated version of the organization's name is recommended);

  • city, country;

  • e-mail address;

  • ORCID.

Author identification. The transliteration of the surname must correspond to the author's profile in databases to ensure correct consolidation of publications and citations. It is recommended to maintain a single affiliation and complete the ORCID profile.


9. Authors' Contributions

Where there are three or more authors, each author's contribution (Authors' declared contribution) is provided in both Russian and English.

Example:

Authors' contributions: Ivanov A. B. — problem statement, development of the article concept, critical analysis of literature; Petrova G. P. — description of results and formulation of research conclusions; Sidorov A. N. — collection of statistical data, tabular and graphical presentation of results.

9.1. Academic Supervision

Postgraduate students, doctoral candidates, master's students, and undergraduate students must provide information about their academic supervisor: full name, academic degree, title, affiliation.

Confirmation that the work was carried out under academic supervision is provided in one of two ways, at the author's choice:

  1. A cover letter or recommendation from the academic supervisor attached to the manuscript.

  2. The academic supervisor is copied (CC) on the submission email to the editorial office (Glavred@legalbulletin.ru). This confirms that the supervisor is aware of the preparation of the publication and that it was carried out under their supervision.

If neither method is observed, the manuscript will not be considered.


10. Personal Data

Submission of a manuscript signifies the author's consent to the processing of personal data to the extent necessary for the editorial process. For more details, see the License Agreement.

Articles submitted without compliance with these conditions will not be considered.


11. Submission Checklist

  • ☐ Manuscript formatted according to the template (.docx)

  • ☐ UDC and LBC codes indicated

  • ☐ Title, abstract, keywords — in Russian and English

  • ☐ References: at least 10 sources, DOI/EDN provided

  • ☐ References formatted according to requirements

  • ☐ Plagiarism report attached (≥ 75%)

  • ☐ Author information, ORCID provided

  • ☐ AI disclosure or declaration of non-use provided

  • ☐ For postgraduate and undergraduate students — supervisor's cover letter or supervisor copied (CC) on submission email

  • ☐ Where there are 3 or more authors — each author's contribution indicated

Table 1 - Structure of the scientific article

 

Метаданные

Заголовок

Title

Сведения об авторах

Имя О. Фамилия

Information

about authors

First Name

Surname

Аффилиация

Affiliation, ORCID

Аннотация

Abstract

Структурированная

Неструктурированная

Structured

Unstructured

актуальность;

основная цель;

рассматриваемые проблемы;

используемые методы;

выводы.

relevance;

the main goal;

the problems under consideration;

methods used;

conclusions.

Ключевые слова

Keywords

Текст статьи

Введение (постановка проблемы исследования, обзор научной литературы в соответствии с проблемой исследования)

Introduction

Материалы и методы исследования

Materials and Methods (Theoretical basis)

Результаты исследования

Results

Обсуждение результатов исследования

Discussion

Заключение

Conclusion

Благодарности

Acknowledgments

Метаданные

Библиографический список

References