Ваш браузер устарел. Рекомендуем обновить его до последней версии.

Vol  11 - No 2 (2026)

PUBLIC REGULATION OF SOCIAL RELATIONS

 

Svetlana M. Mironova, Daniil D. Abesin

THE CONCEPT AND ESSENCE OF COMPLIANCE IN CREDIT ORGANIZATIONS AS A TOOL FOR MINIMIZING LEGAL RISKS 

Abstract. The relevance of the study is due to the dynamic development of the banking sector, the growth of cashless payments and e-commerce, which is accompanied by a tenfold increase in the number of financial crimes and the emergence of new fraudulent schemes. In these conditions, compliance in credit institutions becomes crucial as a tool for preventing legal, regulatory, and reputational risks. At the same time, the lack of a legal definition of compliance, the contradictions between the mandatory requirements in the field of AML/CFT and the dispositive norms on anti-corruption compliance, as well as the conflict between the public legal obligations of banks and the private legal interests of customers, create legal uncertainty that requires scientific analysis. The purpose of this article is to provide a comprehensive theoretical and legal analysis of the concept and essence of compliance in credit organizations, and to identify the legal and organizational challenges in its implementation in the context of harmonizing Russian legislation with international standards.

This paper examines issues such as the distinction between anti-corruption compliance and AML/CFT compliance, regulatory gaps, the lack of standardized terminology, and the imbalance between banks' control functions and clients' rights.
The methodological framework is based on dialectical, systemic-structural, formal-legal, and comparative-legal methods.
The main part of the article analyzes regulatory acts (Federal Law No. 115-FZ, Bank of Russia regulations), international standards (FATF recommendations, Basel Committee documents, and the Wolfsberg Principles), organizational internal control mechanisms, client and beneficial owner identification procedures, and the types of risks mitigated by a compliance system.
The conclusions substantiate that compliance is a dynamic, integrated system that requires constant adaptation to changing threats. Promising areas for improvement include legislatively defining compliance, synchronizing anti-corruption and AML/CFT regulations, further developing a risk-based approach, and improving the professional qualifications of specialists.

Keywords: compliance; credit institutions; legal risks; anti-money laundering (AML/CFT); risk-based approach; internal control; customer identification; Bank of Russia.

DOI

 

Dian Arlesti Lukman

LEGAL AMBIGUITY IN THE INDONESIAN PRESS LAW TO ACCOMMODATE HOMELESS MEDIA IN THE DIGITAL ERA

Abstract. The development of digital technology has significantly impacted the existence of media as a democratic forum. Constitutionally, Indonesian law under the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia legitimizes freedom of opinion and expression. Supported by modern digital platforms this constitutional foundation has given rise to new non-institutional actors in the media sphere, commonly referred to as homeless media. Legal issues emerge because homeless media have not yet been clearly regulated, particularly within the framework of the Press Law. Although homeless media operated by citizen journalists essentially engage in journalistic activities as defined by the Press Law, they remain unrecognized under its provisions. Instead, homeless media are predominantly subject to the ITE Law, which creates potential risks of criminalization. This study addresses two main questions: first, how does legal ambiguity concerning homeless media arise within the framework of the Indonesian Press Law? Second, how can press regulation be reformulated to accommodate the existence of homeless media and ensure legal certainty? Employing a normative juridical method with statutory, conceptual, and comparative approaches, the study finds that the Press Law continues to emphasize institutional and subject-based actors, leaving homeless media without clear legal protection. Drawing upon progressive legal theory and comparative perspectives from the European Union and the United States, the study demonstrates that homeless media can be recognized through a functional approach, focusing on activities rather than institutional form. Reformulation through clear and extensive interpretation of the Press Law is therefore necessary to provide legal legitimacy for homeless media in Indonesia.

Keywords: Reformulating; Press Law; Homeless Media; Citizen Journalism; Digital Era. 

DOI

 

Sophia A. Lukina

TRANSFORMATION OF CURRENCY LEGISLATION UNDER THE INFLUENCE OF SANCTIONS-RELATED CHALLENGES

Abstract. The article is devoted to the study of the transformation of currency regulation in the Russian Federation under sanctions pressure. The relevance of the topic is driven by the fact that sanctions restrictions have affected not only the infrastructure of international settlements but also the internal system of currency legislation. The purpose of the article is to identify the specific features of changes in the functions of currency regulation in the sanctions context, to determine the main law enforcement problems, and to formulate proposals for improving legislation. The paper analyzes the changing role of currency regulation under sanctions, special anti-crisis measures, restrictions on currency transactions, as well as new legal mechanisms for international settlements, including settlements in friendly currencies, digital financial assets, cryptocurrency, and barter models. The study employs formal legal, systemic, and comparative legal methods, as well as general scientific methods. Based on the results of the study, it is concluded that the modern model of currency regulation combines restrictive, stabilizing, and adaptive elements. The article substantiates the need for further improvement of legislation through stimulating settlements in national currencies, developing the legal regime for alternative payment instruments, and streamlining legislation.

Keywords: currency regulation, international settlements, sanctions, digital financial assets, alternative forms of settlement, cryptocurrency, anti-sanctions regulation.

DOI

 

PRIVATE LAW REGULATION OF SOCIAL RELATIONS

Oleg A. Polezhaev

GENERAL CIVIL LAW QUALIFICATION OF SMART CONTRACTS AS A MEANS OF DISPOSING OF DIGITAL ASSETS

Abstract. This article is devoted to the general legal characteristics of smart contracts as a means of disposing of digital assets. Smart contracts are a key mechanism for transferring digital assets, but their legal regime remains controversial and unexplored. The main goal. To make a general civil law qualification of smart contracts as a special form of concluding transactions by order of the Central Bank and to justify their recognition as full-fledged legal means of achieving a legal result. The problems under consideration are the differentiation of the IC from related legal phenomena: computer programs, methods of securing, executing and concluding a transaction. The methods used are: formal-legal, comparative-legal, historical-legal, systematic. Conclusions. The IC is a special digital form of the transaction, which has the highest degree of reliability and accuracy of recording the will of the parties in the presence of objective guarantees of its execution.

Keywords: digital assets; smart contracts; transfer of rights; transaction; performance; obligations; form of transaction; transaction structure.

DOI

 

Artyom A. Gritsenko, Arseniy Yu. Grigoriev

REGULATION OF TARGET CAPITAL FUNDS IN SAUDI ARABIA, THE UNITED STATES, AND GERMANY: A COMPARATIVE LEGAL ANALYSIS

Abstract. The relevance of this study stems from the transformation of classic endowments from passive charitable structures into active institutional investors, as well as the need to improve national legislation on endowments. The primary objective of this study is to conduct a comparative legal analysis of the regulation of endowments in Saudi Arabia, the United States, and Germany. The study examines issues such as split ownership, agency costs, fiduciary duties, and the balance of religious and secular norms in endowment regulation. The methodological framework of the study incorporates formal legal, comparative legal, and systemic approaches. This article analyzes the institutional architecture and legal regulation of waqfs in Saudi Arabia, taking into account the duality of religious and financial oversight, the digitalization of waqf registration through an online portal, reduced timeframes, and the expansion of Sharia-compliant instruments. The article examines the American model based on UPMIFA, fiduciary duties, and tax incentives, as well as the rejection of the concept of historical value. Special attention is given to the German Stiftung (foundation) model, which prioritizes capital preservation and offers differentiated tax deductions. The paper presents a comparative analysis of the three models based on key criteria. Conclusions: despite differences in legal traditions (Islamic law, common law, and civil law), all three models demonstrate harmonization of fiduciary standards, the integration of endowments into national economic strategies, and a commitment to transparency. Based on this analysis, recommendations are proposed for improving Russian legislation on endowments: differentiated tax deductions, expanded asset coverage (real estate, shares, and intellectual property), a simplified regime for small funds, and registration of large managers with the Bank of Russia.

Keywords: target capital, endowment, waqf, Stiftung, UPMIFA, comparative legal analysis, fiduciary duties, and tax incentives.

DOI

 

Maria Gromova

THE TYPE OF REPRODUCTIVE MATERIAL AS A CONFLICT-OF-LAWS CRITERION FOR DETERMINING THE LAW APPLICABLE TO CONSENT TO POSTMORTEM REPRODUCTION

Abstract. The article examines the issue of determining the law applicable to consent for the posthumous use of reproductive biological material in the context of the development of assisted reproductive technologies and the cross-border movement of gametes and embryos. The aim of the study is to determine whether the type of reproductive material can serve as an independent conflict-of-laws criterion influencing the choice of the applicable law in such cases.

The methodological framework of the research is based on formal legal, comparative legal, and systemic legal methods. The empirical basis consists of statutory provisions and case law of the United Kingdom, the United States, and the European Court of Human Rights concerning the use of male and female gametes, as well as embryos, after death.
The study establishes that the legal nature of consent to the posthumous use of reproductive material depends on its type, which entails the application of different connecting factors. A differentiated approach is substantiated, according to which consent to the use of male gametes is governed by the personal law of the deceased, female gametes by both the law of the place of the medical procedure and the personal law of the deceased woman, and embryos by the law governing the status of the child and parenthood.
The theoretical significance of the study lies in substantiating the type of reproductive biological material as an independent conflict-of-laws criterion. The practical significance lies in the potential application of the proposed approach in resolving cross-border disputes and in developing conflict-of-laws regulation in the field of posthumous reproduction.
Keywords: posthumous reproduction, reproductive biological material, private international law, conflict of laws, applicable law, informed consent, assisted reproductive technologies.

DOI

 

Vladislav I. Rezchikov

DEFECTS IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE INSTITUTE OF CIVIL LAW PROTECTION IN THE DIGITAL ENVIRONMENT (BASED ON THE MATERIALS OF JUDICIAL PRACTICE)

Abstract. The article is devoted to the study of the problems of judicial protection of consumer rights in the remote sale of goods through digital platforms based on the materials of judicial practice. The relevance of the topic is due to the fact that the digitalization of civil turnover has changed the ways of placing, perceiving and legally evaluating information about a product, as a result of which traditional civil law structures do not always provide uniform resolution of disputes related to a public offer, a technical error in the interface and the seller's refusal to execute an order. The purpose of the study is to identify enforcement defects that occur when qualifying information about a product posted on a digital platform and determining the consequences of the seller's refusal to fulfill an obligation. The article discusses the problems of attributing a product card to a public offer, distributing the risks of technical failure between the seller and the buyer, as well as determining the appropriate way to protect the violated right when accepting an offer in an electronic environment. The methodological basis was formed by formal legal, systematic and comparative legal methods, as well as the analysis of judicial acts. As a result of the study, it was concluded that the main difficulty lies not in the lack of legal regulation, but in the unequal approach of courts to assessing electronic information and the consequences of technical errors of the digital platform. The need to develop uniform judicial approaches is emphasized, proceeding from the fact that the placement of goods indicating the essential terms of the transaction should be recognized as a public offer if there are signs provided for by law.

Keywords: Civil protection, digital environment, judicial practice, public offer, e-commerce, electronic evidence, abuse of rights, protection of honor and dignity, Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, digitalization.

DOI

RUSSIAN AND WORLD PROBLEMS OF CRIMINAL SCIENCE

Leonid A. Zashlyapin

PROCEDURAL STATUS OF A DOCTOR IN EXAMINATION DURING A PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION

Abstract. The relevance of the research lies in the fact that the procedural status of a participant in a procedural action is an element of the procedural form. The subjective rights and legal responsibilities of a physician, exercised by them during an examination, form the standard form of examination, allowing the evaluation of the results of the action under consideration according to the criterion of admissibility of evidence. A precise definition of the procedural position of the physician among other participants in the examination makes it possible to record the compliance of this position and the actions performed by the physician with the principle of legality, and determines the formation of legal certainty in the examination process. The scientific aim of the research was to determine the procedural position (status) of the physician, arising from the normative rules concerning the participation of the physician in an examination during the preliminary investigation.

The main methods used in the work were the legal-dogmatic approach, modeling in combination with a chrono-discrete monogeographic approach. Additionally, the study was divided into a separate examination of its regulatory framework and doctrinal basis, followed by a synthesizing conclusion. The conclusions formulated in the article are as follows.
The procedural position of a doctor in examinations under the rules of Article 179 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation is characterized by significant uncertainty and fragmented regulatory framework. The doctor is not an independent and autonomous participant in the examination. In the hierarchy of statuses in this action, the investigator dominates. A medical worker is involved in the investigative action based on the discretionary decision of the investigator. The doctor acts as a person engaged by the investigator (parts 3 and 4 of Article 179 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation) mainly for ethical reasons — to ensure respect for the honor and dignity of the examinee of the opposite gender when they are undressed during the examination. During an examination without undressing, the doctor actually performs the role of a technical assistant to the investigator.
Keywords: criminal process, criminal proceedings, participants in the criminal process, subjects of the criminal process, procedural status, procedural position, undefined status, legal capacity, capacity, doctor, specialist, examination. 

DOI

 

Anton G. Monetov

THE GENESIS OF CRIMINAL LIABILITY FOR COMPLEX GROUP CRIMINAL ACTIVITY

Abstract. The relevance of the research work lies in the fact that without a retrospective analysis of previously existing criminal legislation, it is impossible to conduct any comprehensive research, and it will be impossible to trace trends in the further development of the crimes under consideration.

The purpose of the study is to carry out a retrospective analysis of criminal liability for organizational actions or participation in a criminal formation, which makes it possible to identify the reasons for their criminalization.
Research methods: the research work is based on both general scientific methods of cognition (logical techniques, analysis, synthesis) and private scientific methods, the fundamental of which is historical and legal, since with the help of it it becomes possible to trace the evolution of the regulation of the group of crimes in question, comparative legal, which allows to identify how the state reacted to the manifestations of complex joint criminal activity at various stages of the existence of the Russian state.
The object of the study is the social relations that arise when countering the organizers and participants of criminal formations.
The main results of the study: the joint commission of crimes has been known to Russian criminal legislation since the formation of the ancient Russian state. Gradually, it became organized and professional in nature, on the one hand, it was a manifestation of criminal intent, and on the other hand, criminal associations were created to commit state crimes, which led to the formation of a subsystem of crimes that establish responsibility for organizing and participating in a particular criminal formation.
Keywords: criminal formation, community, criminal activity, gang, group crime.

DOI

 

Nadezhda N. Suvorova

DISTRIBUTED DIGITAL TRACE OF THE IoT ECOSYSTEM AS AN OBJECT OF FORENSIC RESEARCH IN CYBERCRIME INVESTIGATION

Abstract. The relevance of the study is determined by the fact that Internet of Things devices increasingly act not only as objects or instruments of cybercrime, but also as independent sources of forensic information about the time, method, actor connection, concealment mechanism and consequences of an event. The main goal of the article is to substantiate the concept of a distributed digital trace of an IoT ecosystem and to develop a model for its identification, preservation and evaluation within Russian criminal procedure. The article examines the limits of a carrier-centered approach, the volatility of network and cloud data, the distinction between local and external sources of information, and the admissibility, reliability and verifiability of digital artifacts. The research methodology combines formal legal, systemic, structural and comparative methods, forensic modeling, analysis of digital artifacts and comparison of scholarly approaches to digital and IoT forensics. The article proposes an authorial definition of a distributed digital trace, a dual classification of IoT devices by forensic role and localization of trace information, a model of the evidentiary contour “device - network - application - account - cloud - provider”, and a TUDR matrix for prioritizing initial investigative actions. It is concluded that traditional seizure of electronic media should be supplemented by ecosystem mapping, cross-correlation of artifacts and procedurally documented preservation of cloud-dependent data, while observing legality, proportionality and minimization of interference with privacy.

Keywords: digital forensics, IoT forensics, Internet of Things, distributed digital trace, cybercrime, digital evidence, cloud forensics, chain of custody, forensic readiness.

DOI

 

Dolgan E.  Ubushaev

THE PROSECUTOR AS A PARTICIPANT IN ENSURING THE RIGHT TO DEFENSE FOR MINORS IN PRE-TRIAL CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS IN THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION

Abstract. In the context of the modern transformation of the national legal system and the priority given to the protection of the interests of minors, the role of prosecutorial supervision in juvenile justice requires conceptual rethinking. This article is devoted to the analysis of the human rights function of the prosecutor, aimed at protecting the legitimate interests of adolescents who have the status of suspects or defendants in pre-trial proceedings. The relevance of the topic is dictated by the need to strengthen procedural guarantees for minors, whose psyche is most susceptible to negative influence during investigative actions. The methodological apparatus of the study is based on the principles of a systems approach, comparative legal analysis, and the study of current statistical indicators of the activities of law enforcement agencies. The central part of the work is occupied by the justification of a number of the author's innovations. In particular, the author's definition of prosecutorial supervision in the field of juvenile justice is introduced into scientific circulation. The author also proposes expanding the prosecutor's powers through the introduction of a mechanism for suspending those procedural measures that have a destructive psycho-traumatic effect on a child. Special attention is paid to the argumentation of the thesis on the need for the institutional isolation of supervision over the cases of minors into an independent sub-branch, having specific goals, objects, and implementation methods to ensure successful resocialization of the individual. In addition, the article critically evaluates the practice of applying the most severe restrictive measures, such as isolation from society. The final conclusions are oriented towards optimizing the activities of prosecutorial bodies and increasing the effectiveness of ensuring justice for the most vulnerable social group, which is of strategic importance for strengthening legality in modern socio-legal realities.

Keywords: prosecutorial supervision, control, pre-trial proceedings, minors, protection. 

DOI

 

Roman E. Shvetsov 

IMPROVEMENT OF ARTICLE 203 OF THE CRIMINAL CODE OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION: A MODEL OF A NEW QUALIFIED ELEMENT FOR INFORMATION ABUSES BY A PRIVATE DETECTIVE

Abstract. The relevance of the study is determined by the fact that the current version of Article 203 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation retains a private detective as a special subject of excess of authority, but does not sufficiently reflect the informational nature of modern abuses in private investigation. The main purpose of the article is to develop a legislative model of a new qualified element of Article 203 intended to assess unlawful collection, receipt, storage, use, transfer or dissemination of legally protected information by a private detective in the course of private detective activity. The article examines the lenient sanction of Part 1 of Article 203, the predominantly violent and security-oriented focus of the current Part 2, the inadmissibility of replacing the professional status of a private detective with the feature of official position, and the relationship between the proposed rule and special information crimes. Particular attention is paid to the limits of cumulative qualification and to the need for explanations of the Plenum of the Supreme Court concerning informational consequences of excess of authority. The study uses formal legal, systemic structural, law-enforcement methods and the method of criminal law modeling. The results are expressed in a draft qualified element, its sanction, crime category and qualification algorithm. The article concludes that a private detective should remain within Article 203, provided that the law specifies the independent professional harm caused to the licensed private investigation regime.

Keywords: private investigation; Article 203; information; qualification; sanction; Supreme Court.

DOI 

 

THEORY, HISTORY AND PRACTICE OF LEGAL REGULATION OF SOCIAL RELATIONS   

Mariya M. Gorbunova

THEORETICAL AND METHODOLOGICAL APPROACH TO THE STUDY OF CONTROL IN THE SPHERE OF EXECUTION OF CRIMINAL PENALTIES OF THE RUSSIAN EMPIRE OF THE XIX – EARLY XX CENTURIES

Abstract. The relevance of the issues developed by the author is largely due to the following circumstances. Firstly, by improving the modern control and supervisory activities of public authorities, sectoral management, and public institutions. In this regard, taking into account the historical experience of the implementation of the control function has a certain value in terms of identifying the root principles of the control activities of various subjects, in reflecting the continuity of common and different views on the importance of control in the past and in modern reality. Secondly, the importance of increasing scientific knowledge in domestic historical and legal science, in particular in the study of the functioning of domestic law enforcement agencies.

The main purpose of the work is to identify the essence of control both in the doctrinal aspect in general and in the historical aspect, in particular, as well as in relation to the domestic penitentiary system of the stated historical period, as well as to establish a periodization of the evolution of the organizational and legal foundations of control in this area.
The article examines the problems of various approaches to understanding the essence of control, as well as to the periodization of the formation and development of the organizational and legal foundations of control in the Russian penitentiary system of the pre-revolutionary period.
The methods of scientific knowledge used are dialectics, analysis, synthesis, method of legal hermeneutics, historical and typological method, comparative legal method.
As a result of the research, the author comes to conclusions about the multifaceted nature of the concept of control in the theoretical and legal aspect.: as functions of the state, as forms of legal activity, as guarantees of legality. An analysis of a wide range of historical sources allowed the author to establish the fact that the concept of control was not fixed in the norms of pre-revolutionary imperial legislation, as well as penal legislation, in particular, and to formulate the author's definition of it. Also, based on the analysis of various approaches to the periodization of the formation and development of public authorities and sectoral management, the author provides the author's periodization of the organizational and legal foundations of control in the field of the execution of criminal penalties of the specified historical period.
Keywords: control, theoretical and methodological approach, function of the state, direction of activity, control function, periodization, system of execution of criminal penalties, Russian Empire

DOI

 

Yuri V. Onosov

LAW-MAKING DISCRETION IN LEGAL PRACTICE: A THEORETICAL-LEGAL ASPECT

Abstract. The relevance of the article is determined by the fact that law-making discretion is usually considered indirectly: through law-making, legislative technique, the limits of legal regulation or subsequent law application. However, it is at the stage of forming a normative model that the law-making subject decides which social relations require legal intervention, what legal means should be used and what scope of further concretization will be delegated to law enforcers. The main purpose of the study is to characterize law-making discretion as an element of legal practice and to define its concept, features and functions. The article considers the relationship between law-making discretion, political freedom of the legislator, technical drafting of a normative act, law-application discretion and defects of legislation. The study uses dialectical, formal legal, systemic-structural and functional methods. The article substantiates the approach according to which the object of law-making discretion is not a single legal norm, but a model of legal regulation. It is concluded that law-making discretion normatively and constructively precedes law-application discretion and should be assessed with regard to constitutional limits, expert review, legal monitoring and forecasting of legal consequences.

Keywords: law-making discretion; legal practice; law-making; normative model; legislative idea; law-application discretion; legal technique; law-making errors; legal monitoring; digitalization of law-making. 

DOI

 

Evgeniy M. Terekhov

THE CRITERIA OF INTERPRETATIONAL LAW-MAKING

Abstract. This article addresses the problem of interpretative lawmaking—a situation where, in the course of legal interpretation, actors create legal norms instead of interpretative norms. This circumstance leads to the loss of interconnectedness between normative, law enforcement, and interpretative acts. The necessary prerequisites associated with this fact are examined and the current state of affairs is analyzed. The main criteria of interpretive lawmaking are identified as key indicators of its functioning. This demonstrates that the issue of establishing and examining the criteria of interpretive lawmaking is relevant both theoretically and practically. The primary goal of the study is to attempt to find the truth in determining the situations in which interpretive lawmaking emerges. The key issue identified in this work is the potential for legal norms to substitute interpretative norms when conducting legal interpretation activities, and the importance of promptly identifying such situations. The author not only outlines her perspective on the problem but also puts forward proposals that can contribute to the development of measures to combat this negative phenomenon by establishing relevant criteria. Based on the results of the study, it is concluded that the most common criteria for interpretative lawmaking should be recognized as the following: situations when subjects of legal interpretation activity issue interpretative acts that do not correspond to the actual meaning of the explained legal norms; situations when interpretative norms are disguised as legal norms, i.e. when the publication of interpretative norms does not reveal the meaning of legal norms, but establishes new legal categories; situations when subjects of legal interpretation activity issue interpretative acts without having the authority to officially interpret legal norms in a specific area of legislation and the authority to generalize law enforcement practice in a specific area of legislation; situations when an interpretative act is adopted in the form of a normative legal act.

Keywords: legal activities, law-interpret activities, interpretation of law, clarification, explanation, interpretative act, interpretive practice.

DOI